Updated
We’d keep his card. That’s fifteen seasons with the same quarterback. The retirement screen has one word for it; you probably have a few more.
These are HuddleSim’s fictional career rules, not real Hall of Fame election criteria or an NFL endorsement.
The grade on his record
Evaluation order: first match from the top. Only the listed fields affect the grade.
Career yards: QB passing / RB rushing / WR receiving.
Excluded: touchdowns, salary, contract value.
| Grade | Requirements |
|---|---|
| GOAT | Yards: QB 70,201 / RB 15,526 / WR 17,551. Plus at least 4 first-team All-Pro selections, 3 championship rings AND 8 Pro Bowl selections. MVPs aren’t required and can’t substitute. |
| Hall of Famer | Yards: QB 52,000 / RB 11,500 / WR 13,000. Plus at least 5 Pro Bowl selections AND any one of: at least 2 first-team All-Pro selections, 2 championship rings or 1 MVP. |
| All-Pro | At least 1 first-team All-Pro selection. No yardage minimum. |
| Pro Bowler | At least 1 Pro Bowl selection. No yardage minimum. |
| Starter | Yards: QB 10,401 / RB 2,301 / WR 2,601. |
| Journeyman | Yards: QB 2,081 / RB 461 / WR 521 AND at least 4 completed professional seasons. |
| Bust | No grade above matches. |
Yards shown: minimum whole yards. Strict comparisons: GOAT (greater than 135% of the Hall target), Starter and Journeyman.
Starter labels his career, separate from his current depth-chart role.
One yard between them
Two more constructed QBs, both retired after 15 completed professional seasons. Each has 8 Pro Bowl selections, 4 first-team All-Pro selections, 3 rings and 0 MVPs.
| Passing yards | Grade |
|---|---|
| 70,200 | Hall of Famer |
| 70,201 | GOAT |
A place in Canton
His legacy grade can be calculated while he’s still playing. To unlock A place in Canton, he must retire with Hall of Famer or GOAT.